Loading... Please wait...

Lies, Damned Lies and Statistics

....FROM LABOUR GROUP LEADER ANDREW BURNS' BLOG 

Lies, damned lies and statistics ... again

This other Evening News story from yesterday - about a possible Council pay freeze - is pretty grim in its telling ... summary follows:

  • Liberals and Nationalists have been running Edinburgh for two years.
  • everything in those two years has been wonderful - everything!
  • everything in the previous 23 years was awful - everything!
  • a Liberal is the current Finance spokesperson
  • he has form on taking responsibility seriously
  • the UK budget isn't set until next week
  • there may be a Barnett consequential, in terms of additional efficiency savings for the Scottish Government
  • it could amount to a total of £500million (that's half of one billion pounds for all of Scotland) for the whole Scottish Government
  • that's not Local Government, but the whole of Scottish Government (NHS in Scotland etc.)
  • but hey, it may be theoretical at the moment, but in a rash of maturity I'll blame all my problems on that possible efficiency saving being fully implemented and a share given to Local Government in Scotland
  • I know I sound like a Nationalist, but I'm a Liberal so I can sound how I like

Grown up politics - just what we need at the moment.

And here's what is conveniently missing from this stunning analysis:

  • funding for the Scottish Government in 2008/09 was £33.2billion
  • funding for the Scottish Government in 2009/10 is £34.5billion
  • funding for the Scottish Government in 2010/11 will be £35.6billion
  • yes - that's right - a real terms increase year on year
  • over £50billion was pumped into Scotland to save Scotland's two biggest banks - by the Scottish Government? ; by the Liberals in Edinburgh? ; I think you know the answers.
  • over £2billion has been delivered directly to Scottish people via recent tax changes (most implemented just a few weeks ago at the start of the new financial year) - by the Scottish Government? ; by the Liberals in Edinburgh? ; I think you know the answers.

This whole approach is highly intelligent and treats voters with the respect they deserve: of course everything in Edinburgh is the fault of London and nothing --- absolutely nothing --- is the fault of the inspirational leadership that we've seen at the City of Edinburgh Council over the last two years.

Promoted by Ray Collins, General Secretary, the Labour Party, on behalf of the Labour Party, both at 39 Victoria Street, London, SW1H 0HA.
Powered by taobase from Tangent Labs. Hosted by Rackspace, 2 Longwalk Road, Stockley Park, Uxbridge, UB11 1BA.